Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

http://www.strawpoll.me/10675320

We've been thinking about condensing the sprite responsibility down to one person. Currently we have one person doing the line art and another doing the coloring.


Take a look at the image above vote for which you like more. We realize the line art is different, but try to focus solely on color palette, shading, and the overall stylistic differences in the coloring. What do you think is best for Echo?


Please comment if you'd like to elaborate.

Files

Comments

afoxbutt

I'm definitely a bigger fan of #2. While I like both, the solid, more vibrant colours of #2 win for me. I also prefer the shading in 2, but I'm not sure why lol.

Anonymous

I'm absolutely in love with the second!

Anonymous

Definitely the second.

Anonymous

i honestly like both but go with the second

Anonymous

I'm really feeling the second one.

Anonymous

I realize we're supposed to be looking past the line art but I just can't. I really dislike #2.

Anonymous

I really like #2!

Anonymous

#2 for sure

Anonymous

I prefer the head on #1 and body on #2, I also prefer the coloring of #2.

RedMane91

the detail on #1 is nice but #2 is more soft on the eyes. overall i would say #2

Anonymous

I like both, but my call is going for number 2! I like how "fluffy" his fur is =3

Anonymous

It's hard to see past the line art, and therefore I'm leaning towards #1. But if you apply the coloring of #2 to the line art of #1 I think It'd be really nice.

Richard

Personally prefer #1. It looks crisper overall and the lighter shade of grey compliments the silvery white fur better, conversely the dark grey and off white in number 2 creates a grittier appearance.

Anonymous

Gotta agree with the above sentiments. I like #2 better, even though it appears to be the same from a technical level.

ocaron

1

Anonymous

Ignoring the lineart, I think the warmer color palate of #2 fits better with Echo's desert setting.

Anonymous

I'm voting on the second's behalf. However I feel like it would not fit his character if you did not add the cross necklace from the first.

Anonymous

i personally like the look and style of the first one more. It fits the character better.

Anonymous

first one fits better

Injy

Definitely the first one! Though he looks so cute in the second one. ;w;