This list isn't perfect or complete by any means, but here are 20 of the most popular girls from my comics. If you don't see a character here that you suggested it means they were not Genesis 3 Females, and therefore incompatible with Virgin Island.
I'm opening this poll up so you can vote for as many characters as you'd like. I'll take the top 8 and use them in the final vote which will be posted on TG Comics soon after Part 9 is published here.
I hope your favorite does well!
Tyler :)
PS: Here's a silly image I made for Thea you may like: