Boyfriend & Girlfriend Pt. 2 (BTVS) (Patreon)

Themes: Consensual, Loving, Big Dick, Fumbling Virgins

Word Count: 2,354

Summary:  Walking Cordelia home after a small argument with Buffy and Willow, Xander is lost in his own little world while Cordelia is seeing her boyfriend in yet another new life. She wants to give him something, but she needs to know he'll always stand by her. She can't handle someone who she loves failing her yet again.

Part 2  

Cordelia was quiet as she walked home beside her boyfriend. Xander would glance at her and smile every once in a while, before turning his gaze back to the empty dark streets around them. The beautiful brunette had never really seen it before, but Xander really had come into his own as a Protector. That had been made no clearer than earlier tonight when he’d saved her from a nasty fledgling that she’d frozen up on and failed to stake.

The vampire had backhanded her into Buffy as the blonde was fighting another monster of some sort. Cordelia couldn’t have said what it was, because she’d been entirely focused on that fanged mouth descending towards her as the Slayer cursed and struggled beneath her, already using her enhanced strength to push Cordelia off… right into the vampire’s approaching mouth.

Only, at the last second, before Buffy could literally deliver Cordelia on a silver platter to the fledging, it had turned into a liberal coating of dust for both of them and when Cordelia had managed to wipe her eyes clean, she found Xander standing there in its place. The young man had never looked more handsome or more appealing than in that moment as he reached down and helped her to her feet with a smile on his face.

Cordelia had given him a very long, very deep thank you kiss in response and then she’d whirled on Buffy as the blonde Slayer was finally standing up, getting in the other girl’s face about nearly pushing her right into a vampire’s mouth. This proved to be a bad idea, because Buffy really wasn’t in the mood to get a dressing down from her, Cordelia knew that now.

Ultimately, it had been her that had gotten chewed out by a Buffy-Willow double team as the two girls ganged up on her, verbally thrashing her for freezing up instead of staking the vamp, for falling on Buffy and letting the other creature get away, and of all things, for bending Buffy’s favorite sword. By the end of their loud barrage, Cordelia had been nearly in tears, though her face hadn’t shown that, merely shuttering to emotionless as she began to shut down.

Unfortunately or perhaps fortunately depending on how she looked at it, her old security mechanisms didn’t really work as well anymore. Xander had gained a deeper knowledge of her than Cordelia had ever originally intended and he could see when she was truly upset no matter how hard she tried to hide it behind an aloof devil-may-care attitude. 

In the end, Xander had stood up for her right then and there, much to her surprise and much to the surprise of both Buffy and Willow as well. He’d told his friends to back off of her, to stop attacking her and to stop victim shaming. It was the sweetest thing Cordelia had ever had anyone do for her and she wasn’t really sure how to feel about it. Glancing at the well-built young man to her side, Cordelia pressed her lips together tightly.

She knew it probably wasn’t healthy, but she kind of wanted to reward Xander somehow. In the spur of the moment, Cordelia reached out and snaked her fingers into her boyfriend’s hands, intertwining her fingers through his and drawing a startled glance from the surprised boy. She smiled at him and he smiled back, making Cordelia feel all warm and fuzzy inside.

All too soon they were in front of her house. Xander walked her up to the front door and made to pull his hand from hers as he turned to go, but Cordelia held on tight, tugging him back even as she looked at the dark house, worrying her lower lip for a moment. Then she turned to Xander and turned on her best puppy dog eyes.

“Parents aren’t home. Come in for a bit?”

Xander glanced at the dark house too, really looking at it and realizing she was right. After a second of thought, he nodded and Cordelia’s face lit up into a bright smile as she pulled out her keys and let them both in. Once she and he were inside and the door was closed and locked behind them, Cordelia took Xander by the hand again and led him up to her bedroom.

As soon as that door was securely closed behind them as well, the brunette beauty turned to her boyfriend and kissed him deeply, pushing her tongue into his mouth. Xander was only momentarily startled this time and within seconds he was returning her kiss just as passionately, his hands sliding down her body onto her ass as he groped her tight butt through her jeans, drawing a muffled moan out of Cordelia’s lips.

They’d gotten very handsy ever since that little roleplay they’d had at school. She’d sucked him off more than once in a variety of different situations and he’d reciprocated by going down on her in return. But if Cordelia was honest, she didn’t really enjoy receiving oral as much as she enjoyed giving it. That didn’t mean she didn’t want something ELSE inside of her besides his writhing slimy tongue though…

Slowly, Cordelia drew a distracted Xander backwards towards her bed. When she felt the soft feeling of her comforter against the back of her knees, Cordelia sat down at the foot of her bed and pulled Xander down with her, grabbing one of his hands and planting it directly on her covered breast while she began to rub his crotch, feeling his delicious cock immediately begin to bulge up, though it was probably already in the process of doing so from all the lip lock.

The two teenagers made out and groped each other for a good long while, losing garment after garment until Xander was entirely naked and Cordelia… Cordelia was just wearing her panties. Xander had never pushed past this point before. Every time they’d played together, she’d kept her panties on. Even when he went down on her he just pushed them aside to get his tongue into her cunt.

This time though, rather than going to her knees in order to take him in her mouth, Cordelia broke their lip lock and caught Xander’s eyes with her own, staring at him in silence even as she continued to stroke his thick throbbing prick.

“Xander…”

He blinked at her, his face heating up at her breathless tone. His own was rather deep and gravelly as he swallowed thickly.

“Yeah Cordy?”

Licking her suddenly dry lips, Cordelia leaned in, pressing her forehead against her boyfriend’s.

“Xander… promise me you’ll always take my side like you did tonight. Promise me you’ll have my back above everyone else.”

Getting the words out while pressed against him worked well, but once she was done speaking Cordelia pulled back to see his response, to look into his eyes and figure out his reaction. Xander’s brow was furrowed as he looked back at her, seeming to be just as searching with his gaze. After a moment, his face softened and he reached up to caress her cheek as he smiled.

“I promise Cordelia. I’ll always have your back. I love you.”

That startled a slight gasp of laughter from the girl, who really hadn’t expected him to say it. She hadn’t expected to believe him when he said it either, but she did. Smiling back at him, tears of joy forming in her eyes, Cordelia nodded.

“Love you too Xander.”

Then she finally let go of his hard cock, standing up off the bed and turning away slightly. Looking back over her shoulder at her boyfriend, Cordelia watched Xander’s eyes widen and his jaw drop open as she hooked her thumbs into the waistband of her panties and slowly began to pull them down her long legs, bending over at the waist with her suddenly naked ass and dripping pussy lips right in front of Xander’s face.

Once she had them at her ankles, Cordelia straightened up and easily kicked them off one foot and then the other, her panties flying off to some corner of her room as she sauntered back to Xander, crossing the two feet between them in one long step and wrapping her arms around his neck as she knelt on the bed on either side of his body. Her cunt and his cock came into contact and both of them let out soft exclamations as Cordelia instinctively began to rub her pussy lips up and down on his shaft.

“C-Cordelia…”

Smiling at her boyfriend’s look of utter surprise, the busty brunette brushed a hand through Xander’s hair, giving him a quick peck on the lips before leaning back again to drop her little bombshell.

“I want you to fuck me Xander. I want you to be my first.”

He looked equal parts amazed, surprised, and happy at the privilege. After a moment, a wide grin spread across Xander’s face and he nodded happily.

“I want you to be my first too Cordelia.”

Even though she’d kind of expected him to be on board given all they’d already done together, hearing him say the words still took her breath away and made her knees weak. Cordelia slumped against Xander’s chest and at the same time inadvertently pushed down on his cockhead, her pussy lips just so happening to be perfectly framed around the tip of his dick. Xander slid into her wet cunt with mild resistance as the beautiful brunette shuddered and moaned at the sensation of him filling her up.

There was no hymen to break, such things taken care of by a childhood of horseback riding. That didn’t mean Cordelia wasn’t still incredibly tight though and both her and Xander were feeling that as he speared deeper and deeper into her and her cunt clenched down around him, trying and failing to resist the impalement on his throbbing cock, especially with Cordelia forcing her body down onto him.

Their bodies were suddenly touching and the two both stopped moving, looking down at the space between them in wonder, Xander’s cock buried to the hilt in Cordelia’s cunt.

“Y-you’re so big Xander…”

The young man just grinned goofily, even as he buried his face in the crook of her neck, nuzzling her and breathing in her scent before finally answering.

“And you’re so fucking tight Cordy. Shit, I can barely move…”

Blushing deeply, Cordelia pulled herself up a little, moving for him. Then she drove her body back down on his cock, moaning as the few inches that she’d let slide out of her were once again buried in her pussy. This continued for a while as Cordelia bounced herself up and down on Xander’s lap, impaling her cunt on his throbbing thick shaft over and over again.

Then it arrived, the orgasm she’d felt coming but hadn’t expected to arrive quite this fast. With a gasp and a shiver, Cordelia came around her boyfriend’s dick, moaning all the while and whimpering needily as she buried her face in his shoulder in turn. Xander chose that moment to spin them both around and Cordelia suddenly found herself on her back with her handsome boyfriend leaning over her as he guided his cock back inside of her cunt.

Her legs were spread around so Cordelia brought them back in, wrapping them around Xander’s waist and locking them in place as she tugged him down to her with a hand in his curly black hair, kissing her boyfriend deep on the lips. They made out like that as Xander slowly and languidly fucked her right there on her bed. The moment was as special as Cordelia had always wanted it to be.

The beautiful girl had never expected to be here with Xander Harris. Not even when they’d first gotten together had she really thought that their relationship was going anywhere. In the end, she’d just liked kissing him for some reason. But now they were so much more than make out buddies. Their bond had graduated far beyond simply enjoying locking lips and Cordelia truly believe she was deeply in love with this boy.

Luckily for her, Xander very clearly loved her back. As Cordelia came around his cock, she cried out into his mouth, the sound muffled even as her pussy’s inner walls clenched down hard around his shaft. Xander groaned right back and suddenly pulled back, ending their long passionate kiss and staring down at her rather panicked.

“C-Cordy, I’m going to cum, I need to pull out!”

He tried to do so, but Cordelia’s legs were locked around his waist and her extensive physical training as a cheerleader left the girl in complete control in this moment. Licking her lips, the brunette grinned up at her boyfriend.

“Do it Xander. I want you to cum inside.”

His eyes widened and a moment later he was doing exactly that as she felt his white hot seed painting her womb white with his seed. A soft satisfied gasp left Cordelia’s mouth and she pulled Xander close, holding him to her as he pumped out every last bit of his cum into her. Together, the two of them shimmied up onto the bed more, until Cordelia’s head was resting on her pillows.

Xander pulled out of her and fell to her side, gasping for breath and staring up at the ceiling in some measure of shock. Still quite happy with her spur of the moment choice, Cordelia turned onto her side and cuddled into Xander’s body, resting her head on his heaving muscular chest as she stroked his abdomen with her hand.

“Just sleep here for the night Xander… parents won’t bother checking up on me whenever they get home anyways. No chance of discovery.”

She was already fading out as she made the offer, but she still heard Xander’s grunt of what she hoped was agreement. The two of them fell asleep like that, buck naked above the covers, sharing body heat to stay warm. Cordelia had never slept better and she’d certainly never been happier.