Home Artists Posts Import Register

Content

hey all!! hope you're havin a good sunday, probably still digesting in the aftermath of thanksgibbon... the Jessica Rabbit animation is going fine as well! if all goes smoothly i could actually finish it late this evening! but the reason i bring you all here is actually because... i wanted to ask your opinion on something that i forgot to bring up last news post!

Currently the system for selecting entrants to the Monthly Animation Polls is that the first 20 comments get locked into the poll automatically, while I myself personally pick the last the 5 comments! I was thinking next month instead I could try picking all 25 comments to go into the poll instead! I have a few reasons for this!

First, I do notice sometimes there's this effect where there's lots of choices people seem to like semi-equally, but there'll be ONE really Trendy Popular Character who everyone knows recently, and that character kind of sucks away all the votes from these other choices making it almost a non-contest. And in similar vein, some patrons have voiced their feeling that only Popular Characters can really win in the polls! Now obviously, to some degree this is just natural! A popular character that everyone knows is gonna gain more votes! And I'm fine with that, often I like the popular character as well myself! But what I'm getting at I think is I don't want the animation poll to just be the "What Trendy Character Wins This Month" poll, if you catch my drift? 

Also, in a similar vein, sometimes I myself have a particular type of animation that I may want to do, especially holiday-wise? And that can kind of get away from me if a really trendy character that has nothing to do with the holiday gets chosen, and sort of ruins my own plans lol. Again though, it's not like I /dislike/ when this happens, but in general the animations tend to come out a bit better and more smoothly when the choices align with my own goals at the time!

Furthermore because the first 20 comments get locked in automatically, I worry that when people check the suggestion box and there's already a bunch of comments, they may think "Oh well there's not much point in suggesting something now"? Essentially I don't want someone to not suggest a REALLY GOOD suggestion just because they think all the slots are gone anyway! I specifically make a point to post the suggestion box at the same time (9am EST) on the 1st of every month, but even so this still leaves certain timezones out! Or people can just be busy with work, etc etc. 

Thus, for all these reasons I would like to try next month selecting all of the animation poll choices myself from the comments! Similar to how I run the request streams basically. And to be clear, this is not me being like, "oh i dont ever want to draw a popular character", there are still definitely going to be times when a trendy character will get onto the poll and gain a huge lead! Popular characters are obviously great, I like them a lot too!! There are definitely times for that kind of thing. I don't dislike trends but I'd just like the ability to have polls without that sort of dynamic as well! Let me know what you folks think in the comments! If people seem open to this I'll be doing it next month!


Comments

FurvusFenix 667

Totally behind the decision, sometimes I don't even vote when I see characters winning by a landslide. I'd also be happy to see you experiment more with what you want! Hope this goes nicely ;)

Phat94

Good decision, well justified! It's a constant joy to be a patron.

That One Guy

I like this idea! Helps encourage more unique characters in the polls

Zig

Sounds good!

Dimp

Wait a minute...every character in the poll is a Worm character! What is the meaning of this?! And why don't I mind in the slightest?! But yes, I am totally okay with your suggestion! It falls in line with my "Let The Worm Take Control More Often" lobbying campaign, so go for it

LagomorphaX3

Past experiences have shown that whenever you’re behind the steering wheel, the destinations you’ve taken us have always been 100% worth it. With that said, I trust your judgement, full steam ahead, Captain err… Doctor!

Johnny

I love This idea! The pull was looking like the Grammys with all the bias votes. Like I said, fire emblem girls, konosuba, and red heads are guaranteed winners. It’s been my dream for someone to draw bell from blood lad. Probably never heard of her and she was probably never gonna win or get mentioned. Any ways this is a good way to see more Variety of characters and discover new favorites and explore creative ideas not possible with some other characters. Big W you now play the part as Congress and can veto stuff lol. But for real I like this idea of “Ooo who’s he gonna pick” and being surprised.

FestivalGrey

"Because the first 20 comments get locked in automatically, I worry that when people check the suggestion box and there's already a bunch of comments, they may think "Oh well there's not much point in suggesting something now"" Can't say I don't feel this... so I think this is going to be a good experiment! Maybe it if works we can change it to be this way, if not then you can always go back to how it is. Thanks for being willing to shake things up!

M-Dude

I like this! Always good to shake things up a bit

Dinobee

I'm willing to give this a shot. You tend to have solid ideas when given the wheel, so I'll trust you. That being said, I still want to keep the current suggestion system around because I still want us patrons to have a solid say in what gets done. Yes, the popular character thing kinda sucks sometimes, especially during months when there is a holiday and there are characters that would be more suited for the animation, but I can live with that. It'd kinda suck if you had too much control and only characters you liked were options for the animation month. Then it just becomes a game of suggest stuff that Worm might like that we might not.

Trey MW

It would be good to try it out for a month! Idk if it'll be more work for you if you have to decide between all the suggestions.

Susfishous

This is a good plan! It'll give some of the lesser known characters a fighting chance

BenRocker32

Yo I’m down this sounds like a much better system

Anonymous

Perhaps 2nd place gets the animation, and 1st gets a sketch?

Gfan98

So does this mean you’ll be doing Pyrrha?

lewdlemage

Oh she was coming regardless! She still is due a sketch I just haven’t had a chance to draw it yet!

HammeredToken

Umm why not try something like cutesexyrobutts where he has two polls and picks a set of unpopular votes and another set of popular votes.... But then that just doubles the work though

MEUPORG490

I have to admit the "first 20 comments get locked automatically" rule was pretty stressful for me : I had an alarm on my phone that reminded me on the 1st of every month of what time I should post my suggestion on Lewdlemage's Patreon (at 1 a.m. in my country). I think this system will be fairer since the priority will not be the speed but the quality of the suggestion. In October, for example, suggesting a character related to Halloween is more interesting than a character who doesn't. So, Let's give it a try ;)

Anonymous

I get what you’re saying, I’m all for this!

N

Absolutely, been a case of submitting a character I think would win as opposed to one that I would prefer to submit for a while now. Much nicer for you to choose outright